Wednesday, September 8, 2010

The Last Legion

This one was a bit of a shocker. The Last Legion, by Valerio Massimo Manfredi, really trudged through what might have been an interesting story in other hands. It is translated from the Italian, so some of the clumsiness of dialogue and character might come from that, but certainly a lot of it derived from clichéd-filled story itself. It's clearly written for movie adaption, and the author even notes that in the foreword, so you've got scenes in the book that seem more like descriptions of a movie than something that belongs in a novel.

The plot revolves around the fall of the Western Roman Empire, and the fate of its last emperor, Romulus Augustus. He is rescued from his imprisonment at the hands of the dastardly barbarians who have deposed him and killed his father by Aurelius and his trusty band of legionaries, who were from "the last legion", the Nova Invicta, which was created in secret by Romulus's father Orestes.

The writing is reminiscent of George Lucas's Star Wars prequel scripts, but you get used to it after a while, and the middle portion of the book (the rescue and flight) trundles along at a good pace, with some nice action scenes. Then it gets really silly, and [SPOILER warning - skip to the end of this paragraph if you're still considering reading this book after the above] it turns out Romulus Augustus's tutor is Merlin, and Romulus becomes King Arthur's father, Pendragon.

A quick web search has shown me that they actually made this into a movie. And it is mostly quite atrocious casting, apart from Colin Firth, who is of course always a good casting choice. Apparently it was quite bad.

Avoid this unless you've got a real thing for Roman historical fiction and you've read all the good ones.

Understanding Teaching and Learning

Understanding Teaching and Learning, by Michael Prosser and Keith Trigwell (who happens to be the fellow who recommended my supervisor to me when I was looking at starting my PhD, for which I am very grateful), is one of the pile of books I'm ploughing through to get up to speed on educational theory in higher education. It's well written, and really focuses on hammering home several key points - that a student's learning outcomes depend on:

a) their prior experiences of learning - whether they had previously had good experiences that lead to quality learning
b) the student's perception of the situation they find themselves in - whether they see the particular learning situation as affording a deep approach to learning, and from this and (a),
c) the particular approach the student takes to learning in this context.

It focuses on trying to work out how to get students to take a deep approach to learning, and tries to explain why they don't in certain circumstances.

I can't recall the last time I read a textbook that concentrates in such depth on hammering home a single set of principles like this; it was a very impressive exercise. In a lot of ways it helped me set into place a lot of what I read in Biggs and Laurillard, so much more of the theory has clicked into place for me, and I'm able to read research papers with a much clearer idea of what they are talking about.

One of the things I find most interesting about entering a new field of study is getting to grips with the jargon, and education is one of those fields where the terminology is multi-layered; words that are in common parlance have a deeper and subtler meaning in books on educational theory, and so coming to terms with the terminology properly lets you understand in a lot more depth things that you thought you understood fully before your started. After all the reading I've done on this journey, and find myself thinking back to previous discussions I'd had or things I had read and pondered, and realizing I hadn't fully grasped the situation. It's also a nifty though that in a year or two I'll be thinking back on my current state of thought and be amused by its naivety.

Back on topic, Prosser and Trigwell = Good and thorough.

Saturday, September 4, 2010

A Stainless Steel Rat is Born

I need to get my hands on the original A Stainless Steel Rat - I've now read two of the sequels/prequels, but can't seem to find the original; my book catalog says I've got two of them somewhere, but they don't seem to be there now.

In any case, I've got plenty to fill in the time until I find it - I've got six Rat books sitting on the shelf behind me waiting to be read.

A Stainless Steel Rat is Born
is pretty great too, but I wouldn't say it's got the zing that Revenge has. It's just a little less slick throughout; the younger Jim diGriz has decided to become a criminal, and decides that to become a proper master criminal he needs to find an expert to learn from. The story that follows, while fast and action-packed, just meanders along in no particular direction. What feels like the central plot of the book is resolved well before the half-way point, and then a lot of other stuff happens.

It's quick, fun, and full of adventure. Certainly not too taxing on the brain, but still entertaining enough to keep you going. I'll certainly read more of the Rat series.

Friday, September 3, 2010

Stories

Stories is a compilation of short stories edited by Neil Gaiman and Al Sarrantonio. It's an interesting collection that is seems to be straddling the boundaries of literary fiction and fantasy/horror fiction. The back cover blurb describes it as "imaginative fiction", probably a subtle way of hinting to the genre fans what's inside without scaring off the general public.

Many of the stories in it were really quite good - the ones by Tim Powers, Elizabeth Hand, Gaiman, and Jeffrey Deaver all left very strong impressions; there were a few weaker ones, but overall the collection was very strong, and had a lot of innovative takes on familiar genres.

I'm a fan of compilations like this; they give a nice introduction to a range of authors that I might otherwise not get a chance to read, and in the past I've discovered some of my favourite author in this way.

Certainly worth a look.

Monday, August 9, 2010

The Stainless Steel Rat's Revenge

It was more than 20 years ago that The Stainless Steel Rat was first recommended to me by a friend, and in the intervening years many other friends have expressed surprise and possibly a little disbelief that I had never read any of them. As a sci fi and fantasy fan, there are a number of these series that I'm yet to read that by all right I should have, from Asimov to Zelazny*. I've read one Harry Harrison, but I can't remember which one. It wasn't one of these.

Revenge was the second written of the series, but chronologically it was the fifth (I found this out when Jen, after expressing her shock and disbelief that I hadn't previously read any of the Stainless Steel Rat [henceforth SSR] novels, pointed out that I should've started with SSR is Born). In any case, it stands on its own quite well.

It starts with Jim diGriz, the Stainless Steel Rat, on vacation** with his beloved Angelina, where they cause destruction and mayhem before turning themselves in to the Special Corps, who it turns out are their employer. He is then sent on a mission to infiltrate and stop the interstellar conquests by the inhabitants of the planet Cliaand.

It's a grand adventure, filled with old school sci-fi technologies. Maybe I've been reading too many tales of the Singularity, but it feels like a pleasant change to be in a universe of starships and warpdrive generators and non-nanotechnology personality surgery. Like a holiday in a country town where they don't have mobile phone signal, and small CRT TVs.

The characters are eminently entertaining; it brings to mind some of the joy of reading The Flashman Papers; the protagonist is shady and self-centred but you can't help but like him and enjoy his adventures. The plot is pretty generic 60s/70s sci-fi, but that's largely not the point; the point is the entertainment of watching the anti-hero weasel his way out of an endless series of traps and tight situations.

So, definitely worth a read. Apparently you shouldn't start with this one like I did; start with SSR or SSR is Born. Though really, I can't see it hurting reading these in any random order at all. I'll certainly be reading more of them.

* OK, I'm exaggerating for the sake of alphabetical completeness - I finally read Zelazny's the Chronicles of Amber a couple of years ago. It was bizarro.

** technically it wasn't actually a proper vacation, but I'll leave the book to explain the details

Saturday, August 7, 2010

738 books revisited

Not much to say but crikey! Google has done an estimate of how many books there are out there, and are 129,864,880 of the blighters. So once I get through my allotment of 738, there are still 129,864,142 I haven't read. I'll be able to get through 0.00057% or so of the books out there.

Sunday, July 25, 2010

Rethinking University Teaching: a framework for the effective use of learning technologies

Rethinking University Teaching, by Diana Laurillard, was a hard slog, especially after reading Biggs and Tang. It's much more technical and jargon-driven, and the author uses words in a manner which just don't match up with dictionary definitions. Having said that, it's an impressive piece of work, looking at computer-supported learning, and how effective the various different forms of digital learning tools are. She sets up a theoretical framework describing how teaching and learning works (the "Conversational Framework"), and then looks at each type of teaching interface to determine how they match the framework.

My personal feeling was that the framework she established was created in a rather arbitrary manner - I come from a mathematics and physics background, where if you're going to set up explanatory theories or frameworks, you bloody well better have solid experimental evidence, otherwise you're just waffling and handwaving. It's taking me quite a while to get used to the world of Education, where the things they are studying are so complex and hard to measure, and the science it's based on (psychology and cognitive science) still so fast-moving and unsettled, that the kinds of hard experimental evidence and proof that I'm used to are a long way off.

However, the value of the framework is not in its explanatory powers regarding teaching and learning, but rather in the way that it highlights the shortcomings of each educational technology, and show what they are useful for. There is a lot of useful information in here about when and where to use video, interaction, discussion tools, and so on; and also in how to mix them.

This is far and away the hardest book I've hard to read, in terms of sheer density and complexity of prose, in quite a few years. And coming from a fan of H. P. Lovecraft, that's quite a strong statement. It reads like an academic paper, rather than a textbook. And since it's from 2002, in technology terms it's almost ancient history, and many of the descriptions are quite dated. On the other hand, pretty much all the technologies she talks about are still with us, and in similar forms. Many of the technical impediments she talks about are largely gone (provide videos on DVD? Pfft!), but the vast majority of the pedagogical issues remain.