Thursday, December 30, 2010

Surface Detail

As I've mentioned before, I can't not read a new Iain Banks novel, especially one set in the Culture. He's a writer was has an astonishing ability to flesh out a universe, to take a few powerful ideas and build a consistent and fascinating world from them. Surface Detail is set in the universe of The Culture, which a number of his other books are set in, so it's familiar to readers. In this novel he bolts on a whole separate set of concepts to this world - that of digital hells that various cultures set up to punish digitally uploaded personalities of beings within their society that deserve punishment for some reason. It's a bit out of place, as none of this was really mentioned in any of the other Culture novels, and it's something that would really be expected to have been mentioned. In that regard, it feels rather clumsily to the existing world, when it could have been set in a new world without the retconning that is necessary here to make it fit.

Other than that, it's a pretty good read, especially once the action gets going. The baddies are (as always in a Banks novel) extra bad, so much so that it's not a book you'd give to kids (I was looking for books for my sixteen year old nephew for Xmas, and considered Banks, but decided not to, what with all the genocide and torture and rape that are so often present in a Banks novel). The good guys are all kinds of shades of grey, textured and three dimensional characters. The Minds, the vastly superhuman intellects that are embodied in the starships of the Culture, are always delightfully entertaining.

It;s not the first Culture novel I'd suggest for a new reader of Banks - I'd still suggest starting with Consider Phlebas, which blew me away when I first read it. And it's probably not up to the standard of The Algebraist, but otherwise it's still pretty great, and worth a read.

Pride and Prejudice

Being the ever-neglectful husband that I am, it's taken me many years to finally get around to reading my wife's favourite tale, Jane Austen's Pride and Prejudice. I've seen the BBC production countless times, as well as the recent movie, and various related TV shows about it, so I'm very familiar with all the goings on, as I'm sure everyone reading this is. P&P is kind of like the Star Wars of chick flicks. So it was interesting to actually get around to reading it. I was travelling, and decided to attempt my first ever bookless trip, and happened to have downloaded the Project Gutenberg ebook onto my iPad, so I read it while working in Saudi Arabia and holidaying in Jordan.

With regard to reading an eBook, as compared to reading a dead tree book, it was actually better than I expected. For all the digitalness of my life, I've always been very fond of the old paper format book. This was the first ever full eBook I've read. It actually was fine. There's a feeling of inevitability to the transition to ebooks - I know that in ten years I'll almost certainly be reading everything digitally, but I've been a bit uncomfortable with the transition. One of the issues is DRM - as with all the other media that have gone digital in recent years, the book publishers have tried to lock ebooks down and cripple them to ensure that everyone who reads one has to pay for the privilege. No more second hand books, no more borrowing books from friends. This is why I'm yet to buy an mp3 or movie online - I still buy CDs and DVDs when I'm buying music or movies. Project Gutenberg puts out-of-copyright books online for free, however, so I wasn't worried about DRM intruding on my life. Having said all that, reading the book on the iPad was fine, and I can see myself quite happily transitioning to all-digital reading, particularly if the licensing issues ever get resolved.

Pride and Prejudice itself was, well, as I expected. The thing that struck me the most was how constrained the characters were by the rules of their society - this struck me more in the book than it did in the various TV adaptations, which I suspect played down this aspect a little as it didn't translate that well for modern audiences. There are a number of times when you just want to yell at the characters to just bloody talk to each other. This aspect struck particularly strongly because I was travelling in Saudi Arabia and Jordan, where there are much more rigid rules about the behaviour of men and women that we are used to in the West - the constraints on the behaviour of characters in the book were similar to the constraints on the behaviours of the men and women around me, and experiencing the book and the society at the same time made both make a little more sense. It shouldn't have felt like an unexpected and strange parallel, but it did.

Apart from that, it's quite a clever book, with amusing and occasionally subtle characterization, and the plot is certainly not spoiled by knowing the conclusion - if anything, the plot is enhanced by knowing the outcome, by the looming inevitability of a happy ending.

Monday, November 1, 2010

Wireless

Wireless combines two things I love - short story collections, and the works of Charles Stross. It has some fantastic stories in it, including the first Stross story I ever read, A Colder War. This is an absolutely brilliant short story, setting the awakening of Cthulhu against the backdrop of the cold war.

The great thing about a science fiction short story is that it's the ideal vehicle for letting an author's imagination run wild. They don't have to ensure character development, or a satisfactory conclusion, or enough plot to sustain hundreds of pages entertainingly, so they're able to freely throw ideas around that might be problematic in a longer format.

Apart from A Colder War, the other standout stories in this collection were Missile Gap, another cold war/sci-fi crossover, and Palimpsest, a time-travel novel that gleefully stomps all over the Grandfather Paradox.

In summary, as always, Stross is a great read.

Tuesday, October 12, 2010

Student's Experiences of E-Learning in Higher Education

Disclaimer: this one is written by people I work and study with.

This book seems to be written more to target people running e-learning at a university than the run-of-the-mill academic (or grad student). It takes the approach that the University should be treated as an ecology, where all the parts need to work in harmony together, rather than as a hierarchy. That the University as a whole should focus on Learning as its raison d'ĂȘtre, since all aspects of a university's core business are about learning - in the case of students, learning to become a member of a community of knowledge; in the case of researchers, learning by discovering new knowledge. It looks at how to try to improve the functioning of a University using this ecological approach.

What made if particularly interesting was that it was written very much from the point of view of the Uni I work at, and examples were drawn from research done at this Uni. The authors, Rob Ellis and Peter Goodyear, are respectively the Director of E-Learning at Sydney University, and my PhD supervisor. So it was quite fascinating seeing how they thought a university should be run, and comparing that to how our uni is run.

Overall I got a lot more from the high-level picture of how e-learning at a University runs than I got ideas about how students experience e-learning at a Uni, but that is probably because it covers a lot of the ground covered in the previous pile of textbooks I had read. The important idea that it contributes to my thinking about student learning is that e-learning should not be considered in isolation or in contrast against traditional teaching and learning methods; but that rather that it should be viewed holistically as part of a larger picture of how students are learning.

Perhaps I got distracted by the big picture Sydney Uni stuff which, from my point of view, came across almost as insider gossip, and was distracted from the main message a bit; but even then this was a useful viewpoint to digest, and will stop me thinking of e-learning as something that has to compete with traditional learning, and lead me more to see how to integrate e-learning with other modes of learning. Certainly, students aren't seeing it as an either/or proposition, but rather as complementary parts of a learning toolkit that they deploy strategically when figuring out how to learn effectively.

Monday, October 11, 2010

Tuck

This is the last in the King Raven trilogy by Stephen Lawhead. I talked about book two previously, and my impressions of the third part of the trilogy are much the same as the previous ones. They are nicely done, and written so that I'll enjoy them nearly as much as my nine-year-old son will.

This one is centered around Tuck, the anglo-saxon friar whose real name is Aethelfrith, but who gets given a nickname (appropriate to his stature) that is more palatable to the welsh tongue. Friar Tuck was important in the previous books, but is central to the plot of this third book. This third book has a wider scope than the previous ones, and Rhi Bran's band of outlaws become a rebellion and have to face battle with the full strength of English might.

It works well, and an afterword tells us (with quotes from Anglo-Saxon chronicles of the time) that several of the welsh kings involved in the story actually did fight the Ffreinc (Norman rulers of England), with some success - the author is defending his tale against readers who will doubt the likely possibility of the events in the trilogy. Tuck is a satisfying conclusion to the story, and is probably the best of the series.

Sunday, October 10, 2010

The Big Sleep

Raymond Chandler's The Big Sleep packs quite a punch. It's supposed to be pretty much the definitive hard-boiled detective novel, and it certainly lives up to that description. Having read it, I now want to go and watch the film. It would be hard to pack as much story into a film as was in this rather slender (by today's standards) novel.

What I love about Chandler's work is the writing. You can't help but sit there in awe at the compact, urgent vitality of it. It is personified in the protagonist, Philip Marlowe, who is all that a hard-boiled detective ought to be - smart, wily, quick, honest (in general, not in specifics) and trustworthy. Marlowe is dragged into a morass of moral degradation and corruption, but comes through clean, and naturally with a clear idea of who the villains are and what they did. It's not a black and white outcome - characters in Chandler's world are all portrayed in various rather murky shades of grey, and villainy is a relative thing, not an absolute.

It was written in 1939, and bears the hallmarks of its era - there's no sign of war or world politics, and the west-coast USA is a dangerous place, full of thugs, petty criminals, and former bootleggers. The language is delightful - partly Chandler's turn of phrase, but partly the slang of the era (obscure enough that some of it could have used explanatory footnotes).

I'm not normally a fan of detective novels, but it's worth wading into the genre just to soak in the sparse, hard beauty of Chandler's words and characters.

Sunday, September 19, 2010

Slaughterhouse-five

Slaughterhouse-five is another of the classics I probably should've read a long time ago. There seem to be a lot of them out there - given my penchant for thinking numerically, I'm starting to wonder if there are more books out there that I should've read than I could possibly have read in my entire lifetime, given my rate of reading. There probably are, and it's likely that I could sit down over a weekend and create a list of 738 books that I really ought to read, and have a lifetime reading list. It's all a bit daunting.

But back onto my topic for this post: Slaughterhouse-five, by Kurt Vonnegut, is an odd book. It's written in a deceptively childish style, and bounces chronologically through the entire lifetime of its protagonist, Billy Pilgrim, centering mainly around his experience in World War Two. Billy's travails in the war are not the glorious war stories you see elsewhere. Billy was at the front, but wasn't a soldier. He was captured, and was in Dresden during the firebombing that destroyed it. He is hurt, humiliated, and dragged around Germany until the war ended.

Alongside that, Billy is somewhat outside time. He doesn't experience it linearly, but jumps back and forth. He learned this from aliens who experience time differently to us, not as a sequence of events, but all at once. It's all rather odd.

It's fundamentally an anti-war book, and this is explicitly stated in the first chapter, which is a (possibly fictional) account of how he came to write the book. He has a character comment that he might as well write an anti-glacier book, since both are inevitable and unstoppable (a thought which travels somewhat unhappily across the years to our age of global warming - we're losing our glaciers, but there are still plenty of wars).

It's a thought-provoking book, but I'm not sure I enjoyed it. The rather offhand style sat unevenly with the deep meditations on war, predestination and free will.